The Wisdom of Crowds is Legitimate

Queen Elizabeth

What is “Legitimacy”? How can you know something is legitimate? Can one thing be more legitimate than another? Can we establish a hierarchy of legitimacy, trust even? Perhaps legitimacy is circumstantial?

Legitimacy is often established because of predictability. Monarchs are not perfect but people knew what they were getting: Monarchs are more stable than local warlords and people understood the social order they represented. Actuaries are not perfect but we understand their motivations: Actuary’s predictions are stable through study and expertise, and we understand the insurance markets they support.

Do you have common interests? Is there legitimacy in an authority with whom you share no common interest? Yes, Actuaries are generally considered legitimate, but their incentive is to push you, the market, to the limit of what you’ll accept. It’s not in your interest to be pushed to the breaking point, so what gives Actuaries legitimacy? The fact that their product sold to investors? Do you believe investors are generally fair or care beyond their financial gains?

Might you, the people you trust, the governed, have more in common with each other than investors? Might the people looking for cover know better what affects them and what doesn’t than actuaries? Can the wisdom of this common crowd be a better source of legitimacy? For those that believe in democracy, consent of the governed is the epitome of legitimacy.

We’ve been through a very similar legitimacy dance with Open Source Solutions (OSS), we won that war, despite lawers still causing problems, and now OSS is not only considered legitimate by the wide majority of developers and enterprises, if you don’t use OSS then THAT’s extremely suspect. We believe Pharo’s Wisdom of Crowds (WoC) will follow a similar path. We believe Pharo early adopters will legitimize WoC in the eyes of the next wave of users, in other words they’ll accept the butcher’s word and eat the T-Bone. We’ll find out for sure as we roll out our MVP and test on kovan, stay tuned 📻

--

--

--

Automated Cover Maker

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Running Apache NiFi on Kubernetes

•love the monkey• Available project Disponibile . . . . #monkey #womantattoo #t…

Monthly Window Based Aggregation In Kafka Stream

Pictorial representation of aggregation in a monthly window

Python Face Recognition with CUDA

10 Swift Extensions We Use at Livefront

Low-Code Development: Why It Is Important and Why It Can’t Replace Traditional Approach

VMware: ESXi Metrics You Should Monitor

GIT Branches

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Pharo

Pharo

Automated Cover Maker

More from Medium

NuGenesis Reaches UNLIMITED Transactions Per Second

Weekly Update — 30th Jan — 13th Feb

11Minutes: World’s First Blockchain Play2Earn Game Series

What sets Web3 apart from Web2

Bitcoin logo